George K. Thiruvathukal, PhD
Professor and Chairperson, Computer Science, Loyola University Chicago — gthiruvathukal@luc.edu (preferred) Visiting Computer Scientist, Argonne National Laboratory — gkt@anl.gov
keylinks.gkt.sh (web)
15th Annual International Symposium on Digital Ethics: MAGIS — September 28–29, 2026
DOI: 10.6084/m9.figshare.33944386
If that reversal is right, no computing technology's ethical questions arrive from nowhere. They are old questions wearing a new interface — and this talk is a history of the interfaces, not a talk about any one of them.
CHOC — "The Core Thesis"
c. 20,000 BCE — notches that made "one" separable from any particular object: the first abstraction underlying computation.
2010s — deep learning, transformers, BERT, GPT-2: "submerged infrastructure" that "few... imagined... could become the basis for general-purpose conversational agents."
Same pattern, both times: the abstraction advances quietly, and only in hindsight does it look like a threshold. That is the case against Kurzweil's speculative singularity — and for the one CHOC says we already lived, in 2020.
CHOC — "Paleolithic Numbers and Calculating" · "Data, AI, and the Edge of Automation"
"We are both monstrous and marvelous, born of ambition and algorithm, living within a culture that is no longer separable from its machines."
— History of Computing and Its Cultures
CHOC — "Conclusion: The Cultural-Computing Singularity"
CHOC — "Paleolithic to Scientific Revolution"
CHOC — "Babbage, Lovelace, and the Analytical Engine"
"She speculated that, given the right instructions, the Analytical Engine might compose music or create art."
— History of Computing and Its Cultures, on Ada Lovelace
CHOC — "Hollerith, Punched Cards, and Business Machines"
CHOC — "WWII: From Ballistics to Electronic Computing"
CHOC — "Mainframes and Cold War Systems"
CHOC — "Time-Sharing and Interactive Computing"
CHOC — "Personal Computing as Promise"
CHOC — "Personal Computers, Interfaces, and Early Networks"
CHOC — "Culture: Playback Media and Electronic Spectacle"
CHOC — "Browsers, Services, and the New Economy"
CHOC — "Web 2.0, Smartphones, and the Cloud"
CHOC — "The Memex/World Brain Throughline"
CHOC — "Data, AI, and the Edge of Automation"
CHOC — "Global Divergence" · "Culture: Feed Culture and the Creator Economy"
CHOC — "The Cloud as Utility and Platform"
Two sources on this slide, kept deliberately distinct: CHOC's own augmentation throughline (bullet 1), and a course-reading argument of mine (bullets 2–3). CHOC ends in 2020, before generative AI.
Course notes cited: George K. Thiruvathukal, "A Pattern of Disruption? Or Yet Another Disruption?," Introduction to Computer Science in Python: Principles and Practice — introcs-python.cs.luc.edu/context/motivation.html
"The resulting Faustian-Turing Type is both monstrous and marvelous, and we are it."
— History of Computing and Its Cultures, resolving the figure introduced earlier in this talk
"The point is not that everyone must become a computer scientist... To ride the currents of change rather than be swamped by them requires a working understanding of how these systems shape production, distribution, discovery, and memory."
— History of Computing and Its Cultures, closing charge to readers
George K. Thiruvathukal · David B. Dennis
Full list: cv.gkt.sh/publications